I have to preface this by saying I do have more important shit going on in my life right now. But to write about that seems exhausting, impossible at this moment. Instead I am going to finish the "Roger Ravioli" saga. Because it is simple and easy to do.
Against your advice, I decided to respond to Roger's email. I'm not sure why exactly. I wasn't going to and then a couple weeks later I changed my mind. It would appear that he read it today. Because he wrote me back. And then he texted me twice. Without further ado, here is what I wrote:
"Roger",
I appreciate your honest email. I am a little confused as to why you're writing it now. What brought this about? It's been so long you could've just let it lie, but you didn't for some reason. Anyway, it's nice to know what actually happened. I had cooked up all these scenarios in my head when the truth was actually just very simple. I wasn't going to respond to this, but I changed my mind.
You are right. I was not affectionate with you. Something was missing for me, and an honest truth is, I felt bigger than you and it made me feel unsexy. You have like 0% body fat. I also put up a wall with you because I didn't feel like it would work out in the long run and I didn't want to get too attached to you.
You're young, still in school and figuring your life out, and deep down I felt like I needed someone older who already had it figured out. I went through that student stuff with my ex and this time around I just wanted to be with someone who was already there. So I told myself it would never work.
BUT the problem was, I thought you were really awesome and I had such a great time with you. I kind of couldn't help getting attached to you. I found you to be so refreshing. You are honest, humble, smart and have this amazing positive personality that is addictive. I loved being around you. You are a complete gentleman and very respectful, and honestly I'd never met anyone like you. And you always made me feel really beautiful and special. You were wondering what I saw in you, so there it is. I wanted you to know that and I think that's why I ended up writing this, against my first instinct.
The funny thing is, right when you decided to pull away, I had decided to move forward. When I was in Fla and you were sick with the flu and said you wanted to go to Alaska, I started planning this trip in my head. I was getting really excited about it, and I was excited to see you because I hadn't in awhile, and basically I just thought "OK, let's do this." But then it was over. And, obviously, I was really confused. I was upset for a bit, and then I wasn't. I got over it. Which is why I am able to write you this without ill feeling or resentment.
I honestly do think you're an amazing person and I wish you all the best and hope you find someone who gives you what you need and who makes you feel as special as you make others feel.
-----------------
And here is what he wrote in response:
Gosh do I miss the hell out of you.
I maybe check my email once a week, and I still think about you all the time... Guess I'm glad you wrote me.
I love life and everything that comes with it, but I would say that most--maybe all things in my life are bittersweet.
I can't really write out sentences at the moment, I just want to yell out various noises.
Janna, if every woman looked like you--men would be very happy and there would be no wars.
If I made you feel unsexy...well that is just down right wrong.
I don't care what room you walk into, you are always the most beautiful woman in the room.
But I was not with you because of that.
You are really smart, I would say sexy smart. Book club = sexy.
Actually (I already wrote most of this email, I'm just adding some)
I just loved being around you. I really loved hearing you tell a story, that was one of my favorite things about you.
Janna, I don't really leave my house much unless it's to play golf, go to work, or go to school.
When do I get off my ass, I feel like it's a total drag and I think about all the other things I could be doing.
When I was with you, I didn't give any fucks about anything else that was happening in the world.
I read a book called "The power of full engagement" and I think about being "fully engaged" all the time because the book makes it seem important. Regardless, I'm rarely ever "engaged" in whatever I'm doing but when I was with you, I was.
Ok, I'm going to go to class and run this through my head another hundred times.
But to touch on your email a bit more, I will have to thank you for all the kind words. I know I'm somewhat of a "catch" (but I really think I'm someone you kinda "learn" to like) but regardless--I do appreciate what you see in me and it's sweet.
I think it's a little funny.
I kick myself in the ass all the time and this sucks. I told myself that you just couldn't be affectionate and I didn't want to seem like a total sissy and bring something like that up because I find it to be somewhat unbecoming BUT you told yourself it wasn't going to work because I'm a young hard working awesome cool dude--I mean I'm a student who lives at home and plays too much golf.
I see this pattern in life and I can't believe I didn't catch it before. My mantra lately has been "no expectations, only goals."
And the problem with this whole situation is I didn't think in a million years you would email me back and say all these genuine things and I haven't been called an asshole once.
Janna, I could really go on all night but I started writing this probably fifteen minutes ago and I had earlier allocated that time to showering and I must get moving! Gosh I sound like a robot
Ok, I don't even know what to say
I'm not ending this email
I'm just going to think about it a lot while I study mitosis.
------------------------
So why did I write him? Because now I feel like I've opened a can of worms. And I knew I was opening a can of worms. So did I want a godammed open can of worms or what? I think for some reason I just really wanted him to know how I felt. But I don't want his words, his feelings. Because even though most of you thought his first email sounded crazy and may feel the same about this one, I understood it perfectly. To me, his words are beautiful and a reminder that a part of me loved him. But I had already moved past this, so what am I doing reading and re-reading this email? I got this email in the midst of a long text conversation I was having with a guy who honestly might be my future husband (more on that later). It was like a cannonball was launched into my happy fortress. Yes, I may be being a bit dramatic but this shit affects me! I was still texting with FH an hour later when 2 texts from a random number show up. I had no idea who they were from, then I realized it was Roger. I had deleted his number you see.
Here they are:
Im speechless
I still remember asking if i could hold your hand UGHHH
-----------------
So that's that. My life feels like a hurricane right now, and this is just one little piece adding to the chaos. Would love to hear your thoughts, good or bad.

